Talk:Armero tragedy/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Malleus Fatuorum 14:16, 7 July 2010 (UTC)

Lead

• "Pyroclastic flows melted the mountain's ice cap, sending four lahars (mudslides) down its slopes at 60 kilometres (37 mi)." Shouldn't this be 60 kilometres per hour?

Precursor

• ... small phreatic eruptions alerted geologists to a possible eruption. These eruptions were taking place when magma touched water ...". Slightly confusing to see those three "eruptions so close together. Could we say something like "These small eruptions were taking place ..."?

Eruption

• "In the Gualí River, a lahar reached a maximum width of 50 meters (200 ft)." Need to decide if your going with the American "meter" or "metre", as you had it in the lead.

• "It is also the deadliest known lahar ...". Not sure about this. How could there possibly have been deadlier unknown lahars?

• "Only one quarter of its 28,700 inhabitants survived". Said in the lead that the population was 29,000. Also, the lead said that 20,000 were killed, so thats a lot closer to a third than a quarter of survivors.

Impact

• "After black ash columns erupted from the volcano at approximately 3:00 p.m. ...". You need to decide whether you want to go with "p.m." or "pm", as the article used earlier.

• "The loss of life during the 1985 eruption was exacerbated by the fact that scientists did not know precisely when the eruption would occur so that the authorities would not take costly preventative measures without clear warnings of imminent danger." Can scientists ever know precisely when an eruption will occur? I can't quite make sense of the last half of the sentence either: "... so that the authorities would not take costly preventative measures without clear warnings of imminent danger." It's partly the "so that" that's the problem.

• "Around 5:00 p.m. an emergency committee meeting had begun, and when it ended at 7:00 ...". Need to be consistent about times: 7:00 pm?

• "... the local Civil Defense director was alerted to the situation. He contacted INGEOMINAS, who ruled to evacuate the area; he then was told to contact the civil defense director in Bogota and Tolima". Which is it? "Civil Defense" or "civil defense"?

• "Because the volcano's last substantial eruption occurred 140 years ago ...". Is that 140 years ago from now, or from then?

  Believe I've fixed everything but the population issue. The sources seem to conflict; I'll try to sort it out. ceranthor 14:49, 7 July 2010 (UTC)

See also

• The See also section should be a bulleted list of wikilinks, not a paragraph of text.[1]

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.