Wikipedia talk:United States Education Program/Courses/Poverty, Justice, and Human Capabilities (Kim Hoang)
 | This course has been the subject of an educational peer review led by an Online Ambassador or other experienced Wikipedian. The review is below on this discussion page; see WikiProject Academical Village-Educational peer review for further process history and guidance. If instead you would like to request a review, please use {{edu review}} |
Welcome to the talk page[edit]
This is a place where you can ask questions, talk about problems, and discuss the Wikipedia assignment with classmates and other Wikipedians.--Ana Builes (talk) 16:26, 21 January 2012 (UTC)
Review[edit]
I think it is a good design. You may want to add tools to aid student's selection of an article to work on, see my course template here, the "Selecting an article" tip. The "and [optionally] introduce the concept of sandboxes and how to use them" sentence may be confusing, I'd suggest deciding on whether sandboxes will be used or not ASAP and removing either the word optionally or the entire sentence. I like that you made DYK submissions non-optional, in my courses it was an extra credit assignment and nobody did it. The one potential problem I see is that some students (groups) have the tendency to edit in the last few days, so you may find that some have nothing for their peers to review. I'd suggest clearly requiring that there is some significant content before the reviews. Feel free to ask any questions on my talk page, I'd be happy to provide more feedback. I am leaving this review open in case another ambassador would like to chip in, --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus| talk to me 15:52, 12 April 2012 (UTC)