User:Selfstudier/sandbox5
Post 2010, for topics relating to the British Left, Muslims, Islam, and Palestine/Palestinians, and only those topics:
- Option 1: Generally reliable for factual reporting
- Option 2: Unclear or additional considerations apply
- Option 3: Generally unreliable for factual reporting
- Option 4: Publishes false or fabricated information <- Do we need this one? Is there evidence? > Possibly yes, the Wadsworth case and Audrey White were fabrications.
- Comment The latest position taken by IPSO is described here (photo 3). Comment by a subject matter expert here. per Press Gazette.
Note to non ecp editors saying cannot vote?
The matters under consideration here may be "broadly construed" as falling under Arbpia rules and the closer is asked to consider whether, in accordance with this ARCA, opinions from editors not ecp qualified, should be taken into account when evaluating consensus.
Muslims https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/uk-anti-muslim-bias-media-report https://english.almayadeen.net/news/Art-Culture/british-media-biased-against-muslims:-report
Reconcile breaches, settlements, uphelds, etc
IPSO
- 1. Mike Sivier – July 2018, IPSO ruling, 1 breach, inaccuracy
- 2. Thomas Suárez – March 2019, IPSO ruling, 4 breaches, significant inaccuracies, failure to correct
- 3. Interpal – August 2019, Legal Settlement, Libel admitted, damages agreed
- 4. Audrey White – November 2019, IPSO ruling, 10 breaches, significant inaccuracies, failure to correct, drawn to attention of Standards Dept
- 5. Jenny Lennox – December 2019, IPSO ruling, 2 breaches, significant inaccuracies
- 6. John Davies – January 2020, IPSO ruling, 1 breach, significantly misleading
- 7. Nada al-Sanjari – September 2020, Legal Settlement, Libel admitted, damages agreed
- 8. Shahrar Ali – September 2020, IPSO ruling, 5 breaches, significant inaccuracies, failure to distinguish fact from comment, failure to correct
- 9. Gerald Downing – December 2020, IPSO ruling, 3 breaches, significant inaccuracy
- 10. Audrey White – December 2020, Legal Settlement, Libel admitted, damages agreed
- 11. Kal Ross – May 2021, IPSO ruling, 4 breaches, significant inaccuracy and failure to correct
- 12. Marc Wadsworth – May 2021, Legal Settlement, Libel admitted, damages agreed
- 13. Jo Bird – July 2021, IPSO ruling, 1 breach, significant inaccuracy
BNS: Hi, I don't know if you think we should include this:
Under the Press Complaints Commission 2010-2014:
- 1. Martha Mundy, factual inaccuracy, mandated correction, 2011
- 2. Collin Leci, factual inaccuracy, mandated correction, 2011
- 3. Mohammed Asif, factual inaccuracy, mandated correction, 2011
- 4. Shareen Gteen, factual inaccuracy, mandated correction, 2012
- 5. David Mond, factual inaccuracy, mandated right to reply, 2012
- 6. Sarah Colbourne, factual inaccuracy, mandated correction, 2012