User:Access Denied/ACE2010

Candidate	User Toolbox	Comments	Vote
Balloonman (talk · contribs)		Not consistently active. Also worried about breadth of experience.	5Oppose
Casliber (talk · contribs)		Editor is strongly inclusionist; worried that she will defend other editors just because they are inclusionist and sanction editors just because they are deletionist.	5Oppose
Chase me ladies, I'm the Cavalry (talk · contribs)		I appreciate Chase Me's contributions, but military service is simply not compatible with ArbCom membership. Arbitrators need to always be readily available.	3Neutral
David Fuchs (talk · contribs)			6
Elen of the Roads (talk · contribs)		Elen has a low edit count, but she is thoughtful and level headed. Her judgement I can certainly trust.	1Support
FT2 (talk · contribs)		Worried about maturity. Seems a bit disconnected from the Wikipedia community.	5Oppose
Georgewilliamherbert (talk · contribs)		GWH is a civility policeman. He is only a civility policeman. He is nothing but a civility policeman. No way.	5Oppose
GiacomoReturned (talk · contribs)		This is a tough one. While it may be good to have an arbitrator who is blind to the mailing lists and behind the scenes goings-on, GiacomoReturned has too much of a history of drama mongering.	4Weak oppose
Harej (talk · contribs)			6
Iridescent (talk · contribs)		Iridescent is often blunt to the point of personal attacks, but excellent content work and good judgement more than make up for it.	1Support
Jclemens (talk · contribs)		I disagree with Jclemens on practically everything, from adminship criteria to deletionism, but I can't see anything specifically wrong with him being an arbitrator.	3Neutral
John Vandenberg (talk · contribs)			6
Loosmark (talk · contribs)		Currently blocked for socking. NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!!	5Oppose
Newyorkbrad (talk · contribs)			6
Off2riorob (talk · contribs)		Not now. Not ever. Off2riorob has a block log much more similar to that of a banned user than that of an ArbCom candidate. Long history of edit warring. Frequently tries to shift the blame onto others. What the hell, he was even edit warring on his own ArbCom page!!!	5Oppose
PhilKnight (talk · contribs)			6
Sandstein (talk · contribs)		Sandstein has a tendency to follow policies to the letter, andheis also a bit too much lf a civilit policeman for my liking. Howeve, he is experienced, sensible, and has a lot of experience, and I trust his judgement.	2Weak support
Shell Kinney (talk · contribs)			6
SirFozzie (talk · contribs)			6
Stephen Bain (talk · contribs)			6
Xeno (talk · contribs)		A level-head and experienced candidate. I definitely trust Xeno's judgement.	1Support