The Case for Christian Nationalism
 | |
| Author | Stephen Wolfe |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Canon Press |
Publication date | 2022 |
| Pages | 488 |
| ISBN | 978-1957905334 |
The Case for Christian Nationalism is a 2022 book by Stephen Wolfe.[1][2][3] The book argues for Christian nationalism based on cultural and ethnic affinity from a Christian perspective,[2] and a retrieval of traditional Christian political thought.[1]
Summary[edit]
Wolfe approaches nationalism as becoming conscious of, and "being for," one's own "people-group."[1] He argues that homogeneity allows each people-group to more properly pursue the good by ordering earthly life towards heavenly life, and that while a principal image of heavenly life can be found in Christian worship, only a Christian nation can provide a complete image.[1] Wolfe argues for homogeneity by constructing a theological anthropology, positing that humans would have formed separate, culturally distinct communities, even if the fall of man had not occurred.[4]
In addition, he argues that this should be accomplished through a "measured theocratic Caesarism".[1] Wolfe follows early Reformers[who?] in assigning the government a role in suppressing outward displays of "false religion", but not a power to coerce the conscience or inward religion.[1] The civil magistrate is tasked with wielding "formal civil power" for the public good.[4] He also argues that Christian nationalism is compatible with the tradition of the American founding.[1]
Reception[edit]
In a review, Kevin DeYoung of The Gospel Coalition gave the book one star out of five, stating, "I understand and sympathize with the desire for something like Christian Nationalism, but if this book represents the best of that ism, then Christian Nationalism is not the answer the church or our nation needs."[1]
Paul Matzko of Reason magazine called the book "segregationist," stating, "Wolfe's ethnicized vision of Christian nationalism is a reminder that, in a post-liberal vacuum, fearful American Christians have become easy targets for people whispering to take up the sword of the state and smite their foes."[3]
Some of the reviews were more positive. Yoram Hazony, an Orthodox Jewish scholar and conservative activist said that the work, "paves the way for a new genre of American Christian-nationalist political theory" and that it was "relentlessly innovative."[5]
James Clark of The North American Anglican wrote that "Wolfe’s account of revolution could be stronger" but he has nevertheless "written something important here, something that deserves to be read and contemplated."[4]
References[edit]
- ^ a b c d e f g h DeYoung, Kevin (2022-11-28). "The Rise of Right-Wing Wokeism". The Gospel Coalition. Retrieved 2023-06-07.
- ^ a b Miller, Paul D. (2022-12-20). "A Tale of Two Books, One Podcast, and the Contest over Christian Nationalism". ChristianityToday.com. Retrieved 2023-06-07.
- ^ a b Matzko, Paul (2023-05-13). "Beware the 'Christian Prince'". Reason.com. Retrieved 2023-06-07.
- ^ a b c Clark, James (2022-11-30). "Book Review: "The Case for Christian Nationalism" - The North American Anglican". Retrieved 2023-06-07.
- ^ Nigro, Jesse (2022-12-09). "Editor's Note Regarding "The Case for Christian Nationalism" - The North American Anglican". Retrieved 2023-06-07.