Talk:Jean Baptiste Beaubien

more work needed

I cleaned up and expanded this article as part of my contribution to Illinois' bicentennial. However, I have limited time and other obligations, so I have no idea when or if I can do further needed cleanup, beyond adding an image of Fort Dearborn if the book PDF ever manages to load again. First, I was surprised by the number of different death dates in January 1863 and January 1864. Since he died in the winter, a funeral may have been delayed in order to secure the services of a priest, or while waiting for the ground to thaw enough to dig a grave. Since his last daughter was born in 1863, the later dates conceivably could be to avoid social opprobrium if she were born late in the year, although even people of that time recognized posthumous births. I don't know the state of DuPage county records of the time, nor of those of the archdiocese of Chicago, which could harmonize the various death dates.I'm also frustrated by the number of unpaginated references herein to Andreas' long book, and don't remember how to add page numbers to multi-cite references.Jweaver28 (talk) 21:16, 20 September 2018 (UTC)

death date

Many different death dates have been published for him, and I have used January 5, 1864 as an best educated estimate. Despite wikipedia's no original research policy, I will try to contact the Chicago archdiocese as well as DuPage County records to confirm. Clearly, Beaubien died in the winter, and priests were relatively rare in Naperville in that era. One Catholic convention of the era was to list winter deaths including both years. Thus, a death in January 1864 would be written January 1863-1864, and some authors may have erroneously edited out the correct year. Although a family tree on ancestry.com gives his death date as January 5, 1863, his family's modern collective gravestone gives 1864 as the year (but includes no days for any family members). Chicago librarian Roden in the cited work indicates Beaubien died on January 26, 1863, but I believe he committed this error and that the late-in-the-month date indicates that Beaubien's remains were held (the climate perhaps providing sufficient refrigeration) until a priest could come and bury him. See Carl B. Roden, "The Beaubien Claim", Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society (1908-1984) Vol. 42, No. 2 (Jun., 1949) p. 165. Unfortunately, Earlychicago.com gives his death date as January 25, 1873, which seems a typo. While Canadian Catholic church records and Cook County death indices are online, Beaubien died in DuPage County, Illinois.Jweaver28 (talk) 17:16, 3 October 2018 (UTC)

DuPage County only has death records after 1877 (and those early years are sketchy). The old Naperville parish records include funerals in 1862, but Beaubein's isn't in them, apparently because his funeral was at Old St. Mary's in Chicago. I don't know if those parish records survived the Great Chicago Fire, but they were lost by 1930; the earliest available records from that parish are from 1931. Perhaps someday a family member will notice this article and confirm his death date using a family bible or similar record.Jweaver28 (talk) 17:07, 5 October 2018 (UTC)