Indian writers protest against government silence on violence
 | This article needs additional citations for verification. (October 2015) |
The Indian writers protest against government silence on violence is a wide spread protest in India. Starting from the beginning of September 2015, disgruntled writers and poets across India have started returning the prestigious Sahitya Akademi Award to protest the increasing incidents of communal violence in India.[1] They believe there is a climate of rising intolerance in the country under the present central government (NDA Alliance). Several elite writers and poets have also resigned their posts in the General Council of the country's top literary body, saying that they were shocked at the level of intolerance on freedom of speech and expression. This incident is also referred to as award wapsi.
Hindi writer Uday Prakash was the first to return the prestigious award on September 4, 2015, protesting against the murder of MM Kalburgi. Writer Nayantara Sahgal[2] and poet Ashok Vajpeyi followed Prakash in protesting the murders of rationalists like MM Kalburgi, Govind Pansare and Narendra Dabholkar.[3][4] They also came out against the shocking Dadri incident, in which a mob lynched a Muslim man in Greater Noida over rumours of eating and storing beef.[4][5] As of 2020, 26 writers are yet to return their souvenirs after declaring the return of awards. Only 13 writers have returned souvenirs and prize money.[6] To prevent return of awards from taking place again, a Parliamentary committee recommended that the Centre should make recipients of government awards sign an undertaking that they would not return them at any stage as a mark of protest.[7]
Sahitya akademi[edit]
List of writers who have returned their awards[edit]
As of 15 October 2015, more than 40 scholars returned their awards:[1]
| S No | Award winner name | Title |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Uday Prakash | Hindi writer |
| 2 | Nayantara Sahgal | Indian English writer |
| 3 | Ashok Vajpeyi | Hindi poet |
| 4 | Sarah Joseph | Malayalam novelist |
| 5 | Ghulam Nabi Khayal | Kashmiri writer |
| 6 | Rahman Abbas | Urdu novelist |
| 7 | Waryam Sandhu | Punjabi writer |
| 8 | Gurbachan Singh Bhullar | Punjabi writer |
| 9 | Ajmer Singh Aulakh | Punjabi writer |
| 10 | Atamjit Singh | Punjabi writer |
| 11 | GN Ranganatha Rao | Kannada translator |
| 12 | Manglesh Dabral | Hindi writer |
| 13 | Rajesh Joshi | Hindi writer |
| 14 | Ganesh Devy | Gujarati writer |
| 15 | Srinath DN | Kannada translator |
| 16 | Kumbar Veerabhadrappa | Kannada novelist |
| 17 | Rahmat Tarikere | Kannada writer |
| 18 | Baldev Singh Sadaknama | Punjabi novelist |
| 19 | Jaswinder | Punjabi poet |
| 20 | Darshan Battar | Punjabi poet |
| 21 | Surjit Patar | Punjabi poet |
| 22 | Chaman Lal | Punjabi translator |
| 23 | Homen Borgohain | Assamese journalist |
| 24 | Mandakranta Sen | Bengali poet |
| 25 | Keki N Daruwalla | Indian English poet |
| 26 | Nand Bhardwaj | Rajasthani Hindi writer |
Statements made by writers[edit]
The PM keeps quiet. Writers are being murdered, Innocents being killed and his ministers making objectionable statements
— Ashok vajpeyi[8]
The country is now passing through very though times. It's worse than Emergency
— Sarah Joseph[8]
We are going backwards. There is rising intolerance
— Nayantara Sahgal[8]
List of writers who resigned from Sahitya Akademi posts[edit]
| No[1] | Writer name | Language |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Shashi Deshpande | Kannada author |
| 2 | K Satchidanandan | Malayalam poet |
| 3 | PK Parakkadvu | Malayalam writer |
| 4 | Aravind Malagatti | Kannada poet |
Protests by Tamil writers[edit]
Sixteen Sahitya Akademi award-winning Tamil writers have condemned the Akademi for not adequately condemning the killing of Kannada writer M.K. Kalburgi and its failure to bring pressure on the centre to protect freedom of expression.[9]
The situation has come to such pass that there was no security for the life of a writer not to mention the threat to freedom of expression. The Akademi has not condemned the act in no uncertain terms. On the contrary it has just issued a general statement. It is not adequate and we demand that the Akademi take a stronger stand,
the writers said.
The signatories are, as of October 12, 2015: Indira Parthasarathy, K. Rajanarayanan, Ponneelan, Prabanchan, Ashokamitran, Thoppil Mohamed Meeran, 'Kavikko' Abdul Rahman, Vairamuthu, Erode Tamilanban, Mu. Metha, Melanmai Ponnusamy, Puviarasu, Nanjil Nadan, Su. Venkatesan, D. Selvaraj and Poomani.
Reaction from Academy[edit]
The academy's president, Vishwanath Prasad Tiwari, countered the writers' claims by saying that they are mistaken in believing that the academy was not responding to intolerance and violence, pointing out that the vice president of the academy presided over a tribute for Mr. Kalburgi in September, where his murder was strongly condemned.[10]
Other award winners[edit]
- Six Kannada writers returned the State literary award on 3 October.
- Theater artist Maya Krishna Rao has also returned her Sangeet Natak Akademi award on 12 October.
- Shiromani Lekhak award winner Megh Raj Mitter has also announced to return his award.
Communal violence pointed out by the scholars[edit]
In general all the scholars have protested the growing intolerance of government supported Hindu right-wing groups against minorities and rationalists.[11]
Particularly
- Dadri lynching[5]
- Murders of rationalists like the Kalburgi murder
- Government Silence on Violence
Controversy[edit]
Former Sahitya Akademi president Vishwanath Prasad Tiwari has claimed that he has evidence to prove that the so-called “award wapsi” movement in 2015, when more than 50 writers returned their awards to protest alleged growth in intolerance under the Narendra Modi regime, were part of a politically motivated campaign organised by Marxist writers and Hindi poet Ashok Vajpeyi to defame the government in the run-up to the Bihar assembly election.[12]
Reactions[edit]
Union Minister and former Chief of Army Staff V.K. Singh claimed that the return of awards by the writers citing intolerance was a planned conspiracy.[13] The then Union Minister Maneka Gandhi said that the return of awards was an international conspiracy against the Modi Government.[14]
References[edit]
- ^ a b c IBTimes (13 October 2015). "Sahitya Akademi protest: Complete list of writers who returned their awards". International Business Times, India Edition.
- ^ "Why Nayantara Sahgal Is Returning Her Sahitya Akademi Award After 29 Years". HuffPost India. 7 October 2015.
- ^ "Writer Nayantara Sahgal Hits Back at Sahitya Akademi Chief's 'Goodwill' Barb". NDTV.com.
- ^ a b "After Nayantara Sahgal, Poet Ashok Vajpeyi Returns Award, Takes on PM". NDTV.com.
- ^ a b "Dadri incident: Urdu writer to return award in protest - Times of India ►". The Times of India. 10 October 2015.
- ^ "Operation Award Wapsi, and the Truth; check all details". Zee News. Retrieved 2024-02-16.
- ^ Scroll Staff (2023-07-26). "To prevent award wapsi protest, Parliament panel suggests making recipients sign undertaking". Scroll.in. Retrieved 2024-02-16.
- ^ a b c "Culture Shock". The New Indian Express.
- ^ Kolappan, B. (12 October 2015). "Tamil Sahitya Akademi winners condemn the Akademi". The Hindu – via www.thehindu.com.
- ^ Barstow, David; Raj, Suhasini (17 October 2015). "Indian Writers Return Awards to Protest Government Silence on Violence". The New York Times – via NYTimes.com.
- ^ "The Sahitya Akademi row: All you need to know". 14 October 2015.
- ^ Venugopal, Vasudha (9 August 2018). "Have evidence to show Award Wapsi was politically motivated, not spontaneous: Former Sahitya Akademi chief - Economic Times ►". The Economic Times.
- ^ PTI (2016-01-24). "Award wapsi a 'planned conspiracy', says VK Singh". The News Minute. Retrieved 2024-02-16.
- ^ "Maneka Gandhi says #AwardWapsi international conspiracy against Modi govt". India Today. Retrieved 2024-02-16.