Beauty beggar
Beauty beggar (Chinese: 美容丐幫; Jyutping: mei5 jung4 koi3 bong1) is a derogatory name for beauty bloggers or beauty YouTubers who capitalize their fame to promote cosmetics so as to obtain sponsorship, in the form of testers or money, from cosmetics companies. It is a Hong Kong internet slang that originated from discussions on Instagram and Hong Kong Golden Forum.[1]
Definition[edit]
Involved Internet users claim that beauty beggars have these following characteristics: some of the introductions are self-contradictory or of poor quality; the declaration of interest is lacking in the presentations; they overcharge sponsorship either from public relations agencies or cosmetics companies; etc.[2]
Tsui Yuen (Chinese: 徐緣), a Hong Kong columnist who specialises in marketing, pointed out that the nature of a beauty beggar is the abuse of the "Word of Mouth" marketing model.[3] Also, Janice Wong, a Hong Kong fashion critic, holds the opinion that the prototype of beauty beggar is the advertorial on "personal media" (Chinese: 自媒體) platforms.[4]
In 2014, after some Internet users reported beauty beggars to the Customs and Excise Department in Hong Kong, the spokesman of Hong Kong Customs announced that they would follow up the case, for the beauty beggars might have violated section 13E of the Trade Descriptions Ordinance, which covers "misleading omissions". The official indicated that different cases vary so more investigation and evidence is required to make fair judgements.[5]
Origin[edit]
Beauty beggars originated from some local beauty bloggers in Hong Kong, who are keen on sharing their experiences of using some beauty products with other Internet users. With their followers accumulating, some beauty bloggers that are more popular may be invited by some public relations agencies or cosmetics companies to promote beauty products. Thus, even if the product is not effective, these beauty bloggers may still give positive reviews on it. Some beauty bloggers were found to disguise the products that they get from public relations agencies as self-purchased products so as to raise the credibility of the promoting products. Moreover, some famous bloggers might sell the samples that they obtained from public relations agencies to viewers so as to earn extra profits. Customers who bought those products then discovered that they did not work or might cause allergic problems. Also, some beauty bloggers price their blog, Facebook page, or YouTube video to ask for extra sponsorship from involved companies. Therefore, some Internet users criticize them as "beauty beggars".[2]
Development[edit]
Due to the increasing trend of using social networking sites like YouTube and web blogs, people love to share their experience of using various products or collect useful information for daily life uses. In addition to the increasing popularity of social network, the continuous inflow of cosmetics and skin care products, especially from Korea and Taiwan, has raise the needs of beauty information for potential customers. Customers believe that they can rely on beauty bloggers' experience to choose the beauty products that suit them most. This in turn created a need for beauty bloggers. Beauty bloggers use either videos or texts to comment on different brands of beauty products after use. Thus, their audience can use their reviews or self-used reports as references before purchasing those beauty products. Some public relation agencies invited them to recommend some products by giving them some testers, but the article they wrote are similar to advertisements, since they simply give positive comments on those products.[2][6]
As YouTube becomes more popular, the sharing form transfers from writing articles to making videos, so many beauty bloggers became beauty YouTubers, who are likely to be paid according to the number of likes for their YouTube clips. It was reported that some of the popular beauty YouTubers even ask for HK$40,000 to 50,000 for each YouTube clip.[6]
Objections[edit]
Some Internet users created Facebook pages and webforums to show their objections to beauty beggars. In order to gather related information and propaganda, Internet users also established their fan club on YouTube platform and set up their database in Google Document and Instagram. In 2014, after some Internet users posted on the Golden Forum claiming that they had obtained evidence of beauty beggars' behind-the-scenes deals, some beauty bloggers were the target of doxing.[7]
Criticisms[edit]
Many Hong Kong Internet users showed their opposition to the beauty beggars, and some of them listed several reasons for opposing them. A famous blogger summarized these reasons why people are against beauty beggars according to their voices:[8][unreliable source?]
- Misusing the YouTube platform.
- Posting advertisements instead of useful information.
- Poor quality of posts.
- Concealing drawbacks of their products and exaggerating the effects of products.
References[edit]
- ^ "美容丏幫風波 － 廣告、網絡紅人與YouTube的轉變" [Beauty beggars controversy: the transformation of advertisement, web celebrities and YouTube]. VJ Media. 8 August 2014. Archived from the original on 3 September 2014. Retrieved 23 October 2023.
- ^ a b c "網民舉報「美容丐幫」" [Internet users reported beauty beggars]. Hong Kong Daily News. 31 August 2014. Archived from the original on 2 April 2015. Retrieved 18 March 2015.
- ^ "十萬緣想：金錢蠶食博客公信力" [Money compromises bloggers' credibility]. AppleDaily.hk. Archived from the original on 9 August 2014.
- ^ Wong, Janice (7 August 2014). "自戀自媒體" [Self-absorbed personal media]. Ming Pao. Archived from the original on 1 September 2014. Retrieved 23 October 2023.
- ^ "美容博客遭舉報違商品例" [Beauty bloggers Beauty bloggers reported for violations of Trade Descriptions Ordinance]. eElderly Hong Kong. 18 August 2014. Archived from the original on 15 September 2014.
- ^ a b "網民熱話：美容博客涉收錢宣傳 隨時月入5萬" [Hot topic among Internet users: beauty bloggers suspected of receiving money for publicity, earning up to $50 thousand per month]. Oriental Daily News. 5 July 2014. Retrieved 23 October 2023.
- ^ "起底揪出丐幫幫主" [Beauty beggars face doxing]. Hong Kong Daily News. Archived from the original on 2 April 2015. Retrieved 18 March 2015.
- ^ "點解要反beauty beggar?" [Why people are against beauty beggars?]. BeautyExchange. Archived from the original on 2 April 2015.