Execution of Poon Yuen Chung
Poon Yuen Chung | |
|---|---|
 Poon Yuen Chung (潘婉聪) | |
| Born | 1 September 1972 |
| Died | 21 April 1995 (aged 22) |
| Cause of death | Execution by hanging |
| Nationality | Hong Konger |
| Occupation | Shop Assistant |
| Conviction(s) | Drug trafficking |
| Criminal penalty | Death |
Poon Yuen Chung (潘婉聪;[1] 1 September 1972 - 21 April 1995) was a 22-year-old female Hong Kong national executed in Singapore for drug trafficking.
Biography[edit]
Born in British Hong Kong in 1972, Poon Yuen Chung was studying art while also working as a shop assistant at the time of her arrest.[2] By her own admission, Poon was a rebellious teenager who often quarrelled with her family. After dropping out of school aged 15, Poon started hanging out with a group of delinquents who spent their evenings smoking marijuana and drinking alcohol at various karaoke bars and billiard halls around Hong Kong.[3]
In July 1991, Poon informed her parents she was going on a camping trip to Lamma Island, but in reality secretly travelled to Bangkok instead.[4] Her family only discovered the truth after Hong Kong Customs and Excise Department officers arrived at their apartment with a search warrant a few days after Poon's arrest in Singapore.[5]
Arrest at Changi Airport[edit]
On 16 July 1991, Poon and her accomplice Lam Hoi Ka (林凯嘉) arrived at Changi Airport on a flight from Bangkok. Customs officer Mohd Rawi's attention was caught by two large canvas bags on the baggage claim belt of Terminal 2, as there were no folds in the fabric at the bottom and he believed he could see the outline of solid objects inside.[6] Poon and Lam collected the two canvas bags and started walking towards the express lane of the customs counter.
After stopping them and demanding their passports, the customs officer noted their demeanor immediately changed from jovial to nervous. Discovering they had both flown in from Thailand, he asked Poon to open her bag for a search. Suspecting the bag had a false bottom, both women were escorted to the Customs Duty Office where a more thorough search could be conducted. Both of their bags had false bottoms made of plywood, with plastic packets underneath containing a powdery substance that was later determined to be heroin. Poon had 6 packets containing 4.4 kg of heroin in the false bottom of her suit case, while Lam had 7 packets containing 5 kg of heroin in her bag.[7]
On 18 July 1991, Poon and Lam were charged with the importation of a total of 9.5 kg of heroin, with an estimated value of $9 million, into Singapore.[8]
Trial[edit]
On 10 September 1993, Deputy Public Prosecutor (DPP) Ong Hian Sun described to the court how both Poon and Lam were stopped for a passport check at the customs counter of Terminal 2 at 11:50am on the day in question. Customs officer Mohd Rawi inspected both passports & briefly searched Poon's bag, before taking both women to the Customs Duty Office for further questioning. After their luggage had been dismantled it was determined that Poon had 6 plastic packets containing 3 kg of pure heroin in the false bottom of her bag, while Lam had 7 plastic packets containing 3.45 kg of pure heroin in her bag.[9]
In their defence, the women stated that they had flown to Bangkok for a 3-day holiday, and while there made friends with a Thai couple named Mr and Mrs Go. The couple took them out sight seeing and on shopping trips, where Mr Go bought them new canvas bags as gifts. Mrs Go then transferred the contents of Poon and Lam's original suit cases into the new bags the night before they flew to Singapore. Both Poon and Lam denied knowing the bags contained false bottoms and that they contained hidden drugs.[10]
DPP Ong argued that Poon and Lam had failed to rebut the legal presumption that they were in possession of and had knowledge of the drugs they were carrying. Their demeanor when asked by officials to check their bags was also important, as customs officer Mohd Rawi said both were stunned when told they wanted to examine the two bags. Their reaction showed they knew they had something illegal in their luggage.[11]
Furthermore, neither Poon nor Lam told the customs officers about Mr and Mrs Go or explained how they obtained the bags on the day they were caught and first questioned. The prosecution also found it unbelievable that that they would not have checked their belongings carefully before departing Thailand, especially since two strangers had provided the bags and then packed them on their behalf.[12]
Verdict[edit]
On 28 September 1993, Poon was found guilty as charged and sentenced to death for importing 3 kilograms of pure heroin into Singapore, contrary to Section 7 of the Misuse of Drugs Act.[13] When Justice Mohidin Rubin informed Poon that she would be "taken from here to a place of execution to be hanged", she reportedly broke down into tears.[14]
Lam, who was under 18 at the time of her arrest, was also found guilty but was instead sentenced to indefinite detention at the President's Pleasure, because the death penalty was prohibited for minors who committed murder or drug trafficking at the time when they were below 18.[15]
Shortly after the verdict, Hong Kong governor Chris Patten wrote to Poon's father to inform him that the British High Commission in Singapore was closely monitoring the progress of the legal proceedings. Adding that while it would not be appropriate to intervene when judicial proceedings were still ongoing in Singapore, Patten confirmed he was in close contact with the British High Commission to determine what possible assistance they could provide to her in the meantime.[16]
Appeal[edit]
On 18 January 1994, the Appeals court dismissed Poon's appeal against her conviction. Her defence lawyer Loo Ngan Chor had argued the original trial judge M.P.H Rubin had erred when he ruled Poon's could not be believed because her original statements to police were different than her testimony in court during her trial. He also asserted that the packets containing the heroin were handled by customs officers without wearing gloves, therefore possibly obliterating any fingerprint evidence Poon could have relied on to back up her testimony about the Thai couple.[17]
Rejecting both arguments, Chief Justice Yong Pung How ruled that Poon would not have mentioned the Thai couple at a much later stage, knowing she was being charged with a capital offence of drug trafficking, if she had in fact not known what was in the bags. Instead of waiting for her fourth interview with police, the court felt that she would have offered up this important information at the first opportunity. Also, Poon had failed to rebut the legal presumptions of the possession and knowledge, as she had been caught red-handed with the heroin in her possession.[18]
In a later interview with the South China Morning Post, which was conducted in the death row section of the Moon Crescent unit of Changi prison, Poon privately confessed to knowingly attempting to traffic heroin via Singapore, saying: "I did smuggle drugs, because a friend had crashed my motorbike, and I wanted money to buy a new one."[19]
Execution[edit]
Poon Yuen Chung was hanged at Changi Prison on the morning of 21 April 1995. As per her wishes, Poon's kidneys and corneas were donated to the Human Organ Transplant Board of Hong Kong after her death.[20] On the same morning, another two Hong Kongers, Tong Ching Man and Lam Cheuk Wang, as well as two other drug convicts (Nigerian citizen Chris Chinenye Obaka and Singaporean national Yeo Hee Seng), were also executed at the same prison as Poon.[21][22][23] Poon, Lam and Tong were reportedly the last three Hongkongers on Singapore's death row to be hanged.[24][25]
Poon and Tong had become close friends during their incarceration, often praying together (Poon converted to Christianity while on death row)[26] in the lead up to their execution, and they were cremated after a joint funeral. The Christian pastor who conducted the service said Poon had written more than 40 letters during her final days to relatives and friends, telling them she had accepted her fate with calm and that she hoped to see them in the after-life.[27]
See also[edit]
References[edit]
- ^ "贩毒者死！ 5毒贩今早问吊 3香港人 1尼日利亚人 1本地人". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 21 April 1995.
- ^ "SHOULD YUEN-CHUNG HANG?". South China Morning Post. 3 October 1993.
- ^ "Rebellion led to death row". The New Paper. 27 July 1994.
- ^ "Prayer on death row in Changi". South China Morning Post. 19 April 1995.
- ^ "SHOULD YUEN-CHUNG HANG?". South China Morning Post. 3 October 1993.
- ^ "Customs officer with an eye for trouble". The Straits Times. 20 July 1991.
- ^ "Heroin worth $9 m seized from two HK teens at airport". The Straits Times. 18 July 1991.
- ^ "Two HK girls face capital drug charges". The Straits Times. 19 July 1991.
- ^ "Two HK women on trial for importing heroin". The Straits Times. 10 September 1993.
- ^ "Heroin-in-bag HK woman to die". The Straits Times. 29 September 1993.
- ^ "Heroin-in-bag HK woman to die". The Straits Times. 29 September 1993.
- ^ "Heroin-in-bag HK woman to die". The Straits Times. 29 September 1993.
- ^ "HK woman to hang for drug smuggling". South China Morning Post. 29 September 1993.
- ^ "SHOULD YUEN-CHUNG HANG?". South China Morning Post. 3 October 1993.
- ^ "IN SUMMARY". The Straits Times. 29 September 1993.
- ^ "Patten follows case of death sentence girl". South China Morning Post. 24 October 1993.
- ^ "HK woman loses appeal against death for drug trafficking". The Straits Times. 20 January 1994.
- ^ "HK woman loses appeal against death for drug trafficking". The Straits Times. 20 January 1994.
- ^ "Life on death row". South China Morning Post. 22 April 1995.
- ^ "Organs gift from hanged smuggler". South China Morning Post. 22 April 1995.
- ^ "SINGAPORE: 5 CONVICTED DRUG TRAFFICKERS ARE HANGED AT CHANGI PRISON". Reuters. 21 April 1995.
- ^ "贩毒者死！ 5毒贩今早问吊 3香港人 1尼日利亚人 1本地人". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 21 April 1995.
- ^ "HK dance hostess among 5 drug traffickers executed". The Straits Times. 22 April 1995.
- ^ "Last HK three to face the gallows on Friday". South China Morning Post. 17 April 1995.
- ^ "Life on death row". South China Morning Post. 22 April 1995.
- ^ "Life on death row". South China Morning Post. 22 April 1995.
- ^ "Organs gift from hanged smuggler". South China Morning Post. 22 April 1995.
External links[edit]
- United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. "Singapore: The Death Penalty - A Hidden Toll of Executions". Refworld.
- Quan, Paul Kaih Shiuh (2004). "Detention during the President's Pleasure: A Foregone Sentence for a Young Person Convicted of Murder?". Singapore Academy of Law Journal. 16: 192.